Monday, June 1, 2009

Всадник привидения: Русский человек мести гимнаста! or Why I haven't posted anything since I first started doing this

I was pretty excited about doing a blog. Unfortunately, I ended up having my computer crash on me due to a nasty virus, so I didn't have access to my laptop for awhile. As another result, I had to reformat my hard drive. I lost some files in the process. Most of them were mp3's and story notes that I would jot down onto my computer, usually things that make a lot of sense as I'm drifting of to sleep (most of which I'd come back to fully awake and wondering why I thought it would be a cool idea for Ghost Rider to be re-imagined as a male Russian gymnast).

Anyways, I didn't lose everything, and I'm slowly putting music back on my laptop. A lot of the songs were mixes that I put on, and I've bought a couple CD's since my computer went down so there's some new songs on there now, too. Same goes for some of my notes, too. Most of the ones that I thought were good ideas that got lost, I still have the same ideas, and some of the better ideas were saved some external drives.

So my computer is similar to where it was before the virus but some of the notes are different and some of the songs are gone. But the virus is gone, and it's moving as fast as it was when I first bought it. So it's kind of like my computer was retconned.

Retconning is one of the most fascinating and frustrating aspects of storytelling in comics. It's a retroactive change done to a previously established story.

The retcon at it's most simple is this: Spider-Man is a popular character, so you can't age him to the point where he is no longer relevant to the kids. So instead of his first adventures taking place in the sixties (when his series started), we're just to assume that they took place in the 70's, then 80's. Aging only a couple years for every ten or fifteen years that the book has been published.

Sometime it's absolutely necessary to keep a character that sells tons of money in licensing young and relevant. Unfortunately, the natural progression of the character suffers. That's why some of the most critically-lauded mainstream super-hero stories (Watchmen, The Dark Knight Returns, The Killing Joke, All Star Superman) are all, to some degree or another are self-contained stories that don't have much bearing on the previous continuity.

A good example of a complex retcon in a comic is the story of the Swamp Thing under Alan Moore's tenure. The condensed version of the original Swamp Thing is pretty straightforward: scientist Alec Holland gets dosed in chemicals, becomes Swamp Thing, plant guy. Alan Moore retconned Swamp Thing into a plant-creature who happened upon Holland during his death. He ended up taking on Hollands personality and memories, but for all intents and purposes was, according to Moore "a plant that thought it was Alec Holland, a plant that was trying its level best to be Alec Holland." In effect, Alan Moore changed the last 10-odd years Swamp Thing stories. They still happened, but they didn't happen to the character readers thought they knew.

Sometimes it makes sense (Batman was created in 1939, yet if you read one of his monthly titles, he's only been doing the crime-fighting for about 10 years) and sometime's it's done in service of the charcter (Batman kills a guy in his first appearance, his "no killing" rule was added to show how his parents' death affected him), or merely historical (Reed Richards and Ben Grimm of the Fantastic Four served in WWII, then Vietnam, then Desert Storm, I think). Sometimes it occurs in television (Kenny returning to life constantly on South Park), and it occurs in the surreal semi-real world of pro-wrestling (try to find a reference to Chris Benoit in anything put out by the WWE after the murder-suicide).

Sometimes it's a simple as recasting a character on a sitcom, like that guy in Bewitched or Carlton's mom on Fresh Prince. Even the term "history is written by the winners" is in and of itself, and idea of retconning on a particularly massive scale. Over the last couple years, and in particular George W. Bush has been saying in press conferences that eventually, the public perception of his decisions will be retconned by history.

Several summers back, I dated a girl for a couple months. Eventually it ended, and because of that weird masochistic tendency to see what someone I used to date was up to, I went onto her blog. She ended up posting a conversation in e-mail with a new boyfriend or some such guy. It was interesting because (at least from my narcissistic perspective) she used all the same terms in this conversation that she used to have with me with the new guy. It wasn't particularly upsetting, the relationship had run its course, and I still thought she was cool. But I still thought, "man I've just been retconned."

But then again, I think we do this a lot more often than you think. Both in terms of what we remember, and we do. I'm sure that if there were snarky comic book fans that read about my life, I'm sure at least one would remark "the Y2 character lost it's edge after he graduated high school. He was a lot more interesting when he was in the marching band and deathly afraid of girls."

(Three weeks mysteriously go by)

I left this blog in edit for a couple weeks, because I didn't want to post it until I had some time to look at it with fresh eyes. Looking back at it now with fresh eyes...eh it's okay. There was a lot more I wanted to write down about how we end up retconning ourselves and our memories or somesuch. I thought about deleting the whole damn thing. But then I would have retconned this blog out of existence. Har de har har (or RDRR).

2 comments:

  1. Great article. I like the way you took the theory out of popular culture and applied it to actual history and then to yourself.

    I've been dealing with this problem while reading the Spider-Man books and, while it's completely necessary, Spider-Man would be over 50 years old by now and have a much different following, it's surprising how history can be rewritten even issue to issue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I'm kind of excited for when you get to the Clone Saga stuff. One More Day, too if the issues on the disc go that far up.

    ReplyDelete